3
Mar

Breastfeeding in Public – Your Civil Right

by Tiffany in Birth & Baby

breastfeeding outside

I think the most important thing you can do for a child is to breastfeed them. It is the perfect food for them nutritionally and since they do not have an immune system of their own for many months after they are born, it is also crucial to their immune health. I won’t get into ALL the reasons why breast IS best now, but you can read my posts on this subject here and here.

One of my greatest peeves is that there is still so much controversy surrounding this very natural process. Facebook thinks pictures of breastfeeding babies is lewd and moms all over the country are getting kicked out of restaurants for feeding their babies in public. I have zero tolerance for that kind of crap. If people have issues with seeing a baby being fed at the breast then they have issues period.

I myself was never shy about breastfeeding in public. I would just pull up my shirt and do what I needed to do anywhere I was. My dad, my brother, my grandfather, my hubby’s friends, perfect strangers…they all got to witness the miracle of breastfeeding up close and personal. I used to breastfeed at the movies when my babes were little and I still remember some shocked faces when they caught on to what I was doing. No one ever complained though….they should have been thanking me because that boob was keeping the peace.

Breasts have a purpose. They are there for a reason. They have a function. To say that using them for what they are intended for is in some way lewd or immodest is just nuts to me. I am always infuriated when I read stories about moms getting asked to leave public places and restaurants when they are doing nothing but feeding their child. It is even more insulting when this happens in states where there are supposed to be breastfeeding laws that protect mothers. It seems though that businesses can get around these laws by claiming they have a right to refuse service to anyone and the mom is usually then forced to leave or be charged with trespassing. If a right cannot be exercised is it really a right?

Well, Rhode Island has gotten it right and I applaud them. A new law has an exciting new twist. Moms in RI  were permitted by law to breastfeed in public but this only protected them from indecent exposure laws (NUTS!) but did not provide them with the explicit right to breastfeed a child in any public place. Like I said earlier, a private business owner could claim they had a right to refuse service and the mom would effectively be denied her legal rights. As of March 1st though these moms can now sue for violation of their civil rights. A right has now become an actual right and any violation of it can result in civil suit. Denying a breastfeeding mom access to a restaurant or public place would be like denying some one based upon race…they can do it…but they better be willing to pay up in court later. I say hoorah!

“Too often, mothers are asked to stop breastfeeding, to move to a private location, or to cover themselves up when they breastfeed at a playground, at the airport, in a restaurant, or in other public places,” explains Dr. Laura Viehmann, a pediatrician in Pawtucket and Breastfeeding Coordinator for the Rhode Island Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics. “This law ensures that a mother who breastfeeds her child in public has the same protection as a woman who bottle-feeds her child.”

It is about time…I hope the other states follow this example.

Tuesday, March 3rd, 2009

17 Comments

  • PrettySprinkles

    Over her in Scotland we have a Law that kind of does protect our right to breastfeed, the Breastfeeding etc. (Scotland) Act 2005. It makes it illegal for anyone to stop a mother from nursing a child in a public or licensed place where they have a right to be. It maybe could go further but it’s better than nothing. Just south of the border in England there are no such laws and I have been offered a table cloth to cover up in a deserted cafe. It seems even worse in the US.

  • http://mariawj.blogspot.com Maria

    Great post! I agree wholeheartedly. I have not had any problems so far (whew), but with an upcoming trip to Milan, I am a bit on edge– not only for the long flight and nursing on the flight, but I am unsure of how the Italians will respond to my nursing a toddler. I guess I am about to find out!

  • http://www.niftythriftyhomemaker.blogspot.com Christina

    I did not know about that, and I live in Rhode Island! That is great! I breastfed my daughter, and plan to breastfeed my next child. I never got rude remarks, but if I did, I would have given them a piece of my mind! Thanks so much for letting me know that my right is protected here in RI!

  • http://sonflowergirl731.blogspot.com Katee

    I’ve breastfed all three of my children, while living in WV and FL. No one ever said anything negative to me about feeding them in public, and just the other day I had a mom come up to me after our 9 y/o daughters’ soccer game and said she was glad to see someone breastfeeding in public and applauded me for it (I have a 6 mo/o baby now). In FL, I can BF anywhere I am legally allowed to be, and no one had better say otherwise! :)

  • http://andiscandis.blogspot.com andiscandis

    Two thumbs up!

  • http://www.KristensRaw.blogspot.com Kristen’s Raw

    One of the biggest things I’m looking forward to with my babies (not pregnant YET, but someday!) is breastfeeding. You can bet your ass I’ll be doing it in public. The more of us who do, the better. We need to show breastfeeding in numbers so it gets more popular and more popular.

    Cheers,
    Kristen

  • Stacey

    I’m glad there is progression on this issue. I am breastfeeding my daughter (I guess it’s considered “extended” since she just turned 2), and I believe we all have a right to be treated fairly, including the people around us in a public place. I also believe in being discreet and not making a big statement about it in public. I think people can be really put off when a woman whips out her boob in public. It doesn’t help the cause, and makes people resistant to hear the real message- it’s natural and healthy and should be accepted/tolerated, not prohibited or a seen as a source of conflict. I am extremely open-minded, but I was shocked one day to see a woman walking through a parking lot carrying her baby on her hip, tank top pulled down, breast fully exposed, baby nursing. Sure, she has a right to breastfeed in public, but I felt that was a bit over the line, if there is a line. It is a little inflammatory, if you are trying to make a point. My 2 cents.

  • http://mostlynaturalmomma.com Momma

    Thank you so much for bringing up this issue!! I have heard too many horror stories about moms who just want to feed their babies in peace. It’s no wonder mothers choose to use formula!

    I am thankful that in the 14 months I nursed my son (and I am like you…just whip it out ) I never had an experience like that. I actually had more than one person come up to me and applaud that I was breastfeeding in public. More people need to do that.

  • http://parentingtips365.com MamaWendy

    It is my sincere hope that over time, the more women breastfeed in public, the more the public will become used to it and educated about it in general. Then hopefully we won’t have to go to such lengths to protect our rights!!!

  • Alison

    Amen! I breastfed my first and plan to breastfeed any others. I never had any problems, but I hate the fact that I live in a state (progressive Oregon, no less!) that doesn’t protect my rights! If mom’s ruled the world…oh wait, we do! We just don’t see the benefits until a few more years down the road. Thanks for the great post!

  • http://julielwillard@gmail.com julie

    I am a breastfeeding mother of an 8 month old and I breastfed my now 2 1/2 year old. Both of my boys have been fed in airplanes, parks, beaches, zoos, restaurants, anywhere and everywhere we go. I have never had an issue. I don’t put my breast or child on display when he is eating nor do I hide under a blanket or wrap. Most people that I have encountered feel that they don’t want to invade my privacy when nursing. I have never taken someone quick look away as disgust. I am very happy that laws have been made to protect those that have not been as lucky as I have been. Nursing is one of the best experiences of motherhood. I encourage everyone to give it a try !

  • http://www.babytipsonline.com/blog Cassie

    I’m in Canada and I feel bad that I have no idea what our laws are here but I’m assuming they’re pretty lenient. That being said, I know there are still a lot of people who are offended when women breastfeed in public. I was breastfeeding at the zoo one day and I was completely covered (you couldn’t even see my baby!) and I was getting the dirtiest looks from people – especially older ladies – that were walking by. Other than that, people are pretty accepting around here. I was lucky I never had to endure being kicked out of a restaurant or rude remarks from anyone.

  • Jenn S

    I breast feed my then 4 month old on a long flight with layovers from Anchorage, AK to Billings, MT and I was really worried before I left that I would get grief for doing it but I didn’t, I think people were just happy that he wasn’t crying on a crowded flight. I tried using the Hooter Hider but he would just push it off. We got really good at nursing in public during that trip, trial by fire you know. Now we nurse everywhere no problem. I haven’t had any rude comments but I would have no problem setting people straight if I did. Thanks for the post.

  • Elizabeth

    Happy to report that I breastfed my youngest just last week at the Art Institute of Chicago without anyone batting an eye in my direction! Illinois has some kind of law protecting breastfeeding moms, but I’ve never had a problem (restaurants, malls, church, music class, libraries, parks, etc).

  • http://www.puremothers.com Deborah

    Has anyone noticed that the restaurants always written about who complain about breast feeding mothers are ‘family’ chain, lower priced restaurants? Is there a possible relation to lower income (the employees there don’t make that much) and less education about breast feeding = ignorance? Hmmm??

  • http://authenticmama.com/ Angie Goodloe

    Can I tell you how much I agree that this! this is one of my biggest peeves as well! Every state should have this law (too bad they have to) I can’t believe people still have a problem with breastfeeding in public! I have 2 – ages 2 and under – I have been breastfeeding for the last 2 years.

  • http://perfectingmotherhood.wordpress.com/2010/05/28/10-things-people-dont-tell-you-about-breastfeeding/ Milka

    I completely agree with your post. I feel lucky living in CA where the law clearly protects moms, both in public places and at work. Out of decency and respect for the people around, I often covered myself while breastfeeding, mostly because I wanted people to think that it was not such a big deal and we should make all moms feel comfortable and encouraged to do it.